FCC Takes Firm Stance on Space Debris with First-Ever Fine Against Dish Network

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has taken a landmark step towards regulating space debris by penalizing Dish Network for its inability to relocate a defunct satellite to a safer orbit. This development emphasizes the urgency of tackling the issue of orbiting space junk and the implications it may have on future satellite operations and space missions.

Details of the Fine

  • Satellite Involved: Dish Network’s EchoStar-7 satellite, was launched in 2002.
  • Fine Amount: $150,000
  • Reason: The FCC found that Dish Network didn’t meet the required elevation for the satellite’s disposal orbit.
  • Official Statement: “This is a breakthrough settlement, making very clear the FCC has strong enforcement authority and capability to enforce its vitally important space debris rules,” stated Loyaan Egal, acting chief of the FCC’s enforcement bureau.

Background of the Case

EchoStar-7 was dispatched into geostationary orbit, a region 22,000 miles above the equator. In 2012, Dish Network agreed, as part of a 10-year extension on the satellite’s operational life, to elevate the satellite approximately 300 kilometers above its current position by 2022. This plan was based on fuel estimates.

However, a few months prior to the proposed end-of-mission maneuver in May 2022, Dish discovered that the satellite had insufficient propellant. Consequently, the satellite was relegated to an orbit only 122 kilometers above the geostationary arc, failing to meet the agreed-upon disposal orbit, and resulting in a breach of the company’s FCC license terms.

In response to the FCC’s accusations, Dish stated that EchoStar-7 was an older model, previously exempted from the FCC’s minimum disposal orbit rule, emphasizing their history of securely managing their satellite fleet.

The Growing Threat of Space Debris

With increasing human activities in space, the risk associated with floating space junk has grown exponentially. These threats include:

  • Risk to Active Satellites: The presence of uncontrolled debris poses a danger to operational satellites, leading to potential damages or disruptions in critical services.
  • Risk to Space Missions: The debris can jeopardize space missions, endangering astronauts aboard the International Space Station and other space facilities.
  • Collisions: Space junk, on collision with other debris, can fragment into smaller, equally hazardous pieces, escalating the overall risk.

According to the European Space Agency, there are over 34,000 pieces of space debris that can cause significant damage upon collision. A report from the Natural History Museum also highlighted dozens of near-collisions that occur annually.

FCC’s Initiatives

Recognizing the increasing threats posed by space debris, the FCC has taken several notable steps:

  • Regulations: In 2022, the FCC introduced a regulation demanding satellite operators dispose of their defunct satellites within five years post-mission completion.
  • Establishment of Space Bureau: The commission recently founded a Space Bureau, aiming to better implement regulations to mitigate space debris and avoid satellite interference.

Future Implications

While the FCC’s action against Dish Network sets a significant precedent, its long-term impact remains to be seen. If these fines can influence satellite operators to improve post-mission disposal plans, it’s a move in the right direction. However, the challenge remains in addressing the vast amounts of existing space debris. Comprehensive strategies, combining regulatory enforcement and innovative solutions, are needed to address this growing concern.

Advancements in Space Debris Management

With increasing awareness about the threats posed by space debris, researchers and space agencies worldwide have embarked on missions to devise solutions for effective space junk management.

Technological Innovations

Several space organizations and private companies are exploring technological innovations to handle the existing space debris. Some proposed solutions include:

  • Space Nets: Large nets designed to capture space debris and safely de-orbit them.
  • Magnetic Fields: Using magnetic fields to attract and collect metallic debris.
  • Laser Brooming: High-powered lasers aimed at debris, altering their trajectory and forcing them to re-enter Earth’s atmosphere, where they would burn up.
  • Robotic Arms: Satellites equipped with robotic arms to grasp and relocate or de-orbit junk.


Space debris management is a multifaceted challenge, requiring technological innovations, stringent regulatory frameworks, and global collaborations. The FCC’s recent enforcement action against Dish Network underscores the gravity of the situation. As human ambitions continue to stretch the boundaries of space exploration, sustainable and responsible space activities become paramount. It’s not just about penalizing non-compliance; it’s about envisioning a future where space remains accessible and safe for generations to come.

To learn more about space debris and its potential implications, visit the European Space Agency’s dedicated page on the topic.